Home › Tools & DIY › How to Remove a Stripped or Broken Screw the Right Way
Tools & DIY

How to Remove a Stripped or Broken Screw the Right Way

P By the Pickpedia Team ·1 picks compared ·Last verified October 2026
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Pickpedia earns from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are paid links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never affects our picks or scores.

A stripped screw stops a job cold, but the fix follows a clear sequence. Here is how the tools work together.

Mark the center first

Use a center punch to dimple the middle of the damaged head. That small mark stops your drill bit from walking or sliding across the surface once you start cutting.

Drill counterclockwise

Left-hand bits cut in reverse. Set the drill to counterclockwise and let the bit bite. Many screws simply back out during this step, no extractor required.

Seat the extractor

If the screw stays put, insert a spiral-flute extractor into the drilled hole. As it grips and turns, it draws the fastener out. A good stripped screw extractor set pairs matched bits and extractors for this exact handoff.

Know the material limits

Standard extractor bits handle carbon steel, cast iron, copper, and aluminum. Very hard alloys and 440-series stainless resist them, so identify the fastener before you commit.

Control your speed

Slow rotation gives control and reduces the chance of snapping a bit inside the hole. Ease off the trigger and let the tool work rather than forcing it.

The bottom line

Mark, drill in reverse, then extract only if needed. Respect the material limits and keep speeds low, and most stripped fasteners come free without drama.

How to Remove a Stripped or Broken Screw the Right Way at a glance

PickProductBest forMain advantageMain limitation
#1 15-Piece Stripped Screw Extractor Set with Left-Hand Bits removing stripped or broken everyday fasteners Two-stage system tackles tough fasteners Will not defeat 440-series stainless
Why you can trust this guide

We compared these picks using verified manufacturer specifications, current retailer listings, and patterns in owner feedback, alongside editorial research. We focus on measurable differences such as performance, capacity, usability, and build quality. Pickpedia does not present editorial research as laboratory testing, and we do not claim hands-on testing unless it was actually performed.

Our top picks

1
15-Piece Stripped Screw Extractor Set with Left-Hand Bits
Best Overall

15-Piece Stripped Screw Extractor Set with Left-Hand Bits

Best for removing stripped or broken everyday fasteners
8.4/ 10 Pickpedia editorial score

This 15-piece kit targets stripped, broken, and damaged screws, studs, and bolts that a screwdriver can no longer grip. It pairs seven 6542 HSS left-hand drill bits with seven spiral-flute extractors, plus one center punch. The maker cites hardness up to 63 HRC and 35# CR-MO steel extractors. Coverage spans roughly M3 to M18. It is built for automotive, maintenance, and heavier DIY removal jobs.

Pieces15 (10 plus 4 plus 1)
Drill bits7 left-hand, 6542 HSS
Extractors7 spiral-flute, sizes 1 to 5
Center punch1 included
Bit hardnessUp to 63 HRC (maker-stated)
Extractor steel35# CR-MO
Fastener rangeAbout M3 to M18
StorageIncluded case
Pros
  • Two-stage system tackles tough fasteners
  • Left-hand bits often back screws out alone
  • 6542 HSS bits rated up to 63 HRC
  • CR-MO extractors add strength
  • Center punch reduces bit walking
  • Broad M3 to M18 coverage
Cons
  • Will not defeat 440-series stainless
  • Hardness figures are maker-stated
  • Needs counterclockwise drill setting
  • Slow, controlled speed required for control
Read our full review → Check price on Amazon ›
Note: Availability and specifications change often. Always confirm the current details on Amazon before buying.

More from Tools & DIY

Tire Pressure Explained: Why It Matters and How to Check It
Tools & DIY

Tire Pressure Explained: Why It Matters and How to Check It

Hose Nozzle vs Pressure Washer: Which Do You Actually Need?
Tools & DIY

Hose Nozzle vs Pressure Washer: Which Do You Actually Need?

Bar Stool Height Guide: Counter, Bar and Table Heights Explained
Tools & DIY

Bar Stool Height Guide: Counter, Bar and Table Heights Explained