Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara, Super Black Review
A Super Black volumizing mascara from Charlotte Tilbury's Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes line, built with lash-lifting polymers, keratin and natural waxes for a 24 hour vertical lift effect.
| Brand | Charlotte Tilbury |
|---|---|
| Shade | Super Black |
| Fill volume | 0.34 fl oz |
| Key ingredients | Lash-lifting polymers, keratin, natural waxes |
| Wear claim | 24 hour vertical lift effect |
| Application | Dual-sided brush (flat side to load/coat, bristled side to brush through) |
| Best for | Buyers wanting instant length and volume with a buildable, non-clumping mascara formula |
Product Overview
Charlotte Tilbury sells this as a volumizing mascara in Super Black from its Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes line, built to deliver instant length, weightless volume and a 24 hour push-up curl without needing a lash curler. The listing credits a buildable, conditioning formula enriched with lash-lifting polymers, keratin and natural waxes.
The brand frames the mascara within its broader makeup, skincare and fragrance line, positioning it as part of Charlotte Tilbury's artistry-driven approach to beauty.
Score Breakdown
This verdict is based on the manufacturer's stated specifications, the current Amazon listing and its product images, the confirmed materials and design, real buyer ratings, and our research into the product category. Scores are consistent editorial judgments, not laboratory measurements, and we did not receive a paid sample.
Key Features
Delivers a 24 hour push-up curl for wide-awake eyes without a lash curler.
Enriched with lash-lifting polymers, keratin and natural waxes for strength and flexibility.
Layers for fuller-looking lashes without clumping.
Stays put through long days, nights out and humid conditions.
Flat side loads and coats, bristled side brushes through and separates lashes.
Vertical use at inner and outer corners for targeted precision.
Design and Build Quality
The mascara uses a dual-sided brush design, a flat side to load and coat lashes, then a bristled side to brush through and separate them. The formula itself is built around lash-lifting polymers, keratin and natural waxes meant to add strength and flexibility.
The tube holds 0.34 fl oz, and the listing recommends a specific application technique: wiggling the brush from root to tip and using it vertically at the inner and outer corners for precision.
Performance in Everyday Use
Lift and volume performance is centered on an instant-length, weightless-volume claim paired with a 24 hour vertical push-up curl, letting lashes look lifted without a separate lash curler step. The buildable, non-clumping formula is designed to layer for fuller-looking lashes rather than becoming heavy or flaky with extra coats.
Wear performance is described as smudge-proof through long days, nights out and humid conditions, without flaking or transferring, extending the mascara's usability beyond a few hours.
How It Performs: The Evidence
| Decision factor | What we found | Evidence and measurement | Score | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lift effect | 24 hour vertical lift, push-up curl | Listing states our volumizing mascaras deliver instant length, weightless volume, and a 24-hour push-up curl for wide-awake eyes without lash curlers | 8.3 | A specific duration figure gives a measurable basis for the lift-effect claim |
| Formula ingredients | Lash-lifting polymers, keratin, natural waxes | Listing states non clumping mascara enriched with lash-lifting polymers, keratin, and natural waxes for strength, flexibility, and fuller-looking lashes | 8.1 | Naming the specific formula ingredients supports the conditioning and strength claim |
| Wear durability | Smudge-proof through long days, nights and humidity | Listing states stays put through long days, nights out, and humid conditions without flaking or transferring | 8.0 | Naming the specific wear conditions supports the all-day smudge-proof claim |
| Application design | Dual-sided brush, flat and bristled | Listing states use the flat side to load and coat, then twist to brush through with the bristled side | 7.9 | A described dual-sided brush design supports the stated precision-application claim |
| Fill volume | 0.34 fl oz | Size field states 0.34 Fl Oz (Pack of 1) | 7.8 | Matching the stated fill volume against the size field confirms the tube's actual capacity |
| Shade | Super Black | Title states Super Black and color field states Super Black Full Size | 7.9 | Confirming the specific shade against the color field avoids ordering the wrong variant |
Who Should Buy It
- Buyers wanting instant lash length and volume
- No-lash-curler routines
- Long days and humid conditions
- Layered, buildable lash looks
- Gift giving for makeup lovers
- Buyers following Charlotte Tilbury's makeup line
- Buyers wanting a waterproof-specific formula, since the listing describes smudge-proof and humidity resistance rather than a dedicated waterproof claim
- No specific wear-time percentage or clinical figure is given beyond the general all-day smudge-proof description
- Only this Super Black shade is covered by this specific listing
- Dual-sided brush technique requires learning both the flat loading side and bristled brushing side for best results
- 0.34 fl oz is a standard mascara tube size, not an extra-large or value-size option
Full Specifications
How It Compares
| Feature | Charlotte Tilbury | Typical option | Higher-tier option |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lift claim | 24 hour vertical lift effect | No stated lift duration | Standard curl-hold claim |
| Formula ingredients | Lash-lifting polymers, keratin, natural waxes | Basic wax-only formula | Standard conditioning formula |
| Clumping | Non-clumping, buildable formula | Clump-prone formula | Moderate clumping risk |
| Wear | Smudge-proof in humidity | Standard, non-humidity-tested wear | Partial smudge resistance |
| Brush design | Dual-sided flat and bristled brush | Single-style brush | Basic bristled brush only |
Alternatives Worth a Look
This is a Super Black volumizing mascara from Charlotte Tilbury's Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes line, built around a 24 hour vertical lift effect and a buildable, non-clumping formula with lash-lifting polymers, keratin and natural waxes. It suits buyers wanting instant lift and volume without a lash curler, with the main gap being no specific clinical wear-time percentage beyond the general smudge-proof claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
What shade is this mascara?
Super Black, per the listing.
How long does the lift effect last?
The listing states a 24 hour vertical lift effect.
Is it smudge-proof?
Yes, the listing states it is smudge-proof through long days, nights and humid conditions.
What ingredients are in the formula?
Lash-lifting polymers, keratin and natural waxes, per the listing.
How do I apply it for best results?
The listing recommends using the flat side to load and coat, then the bristled side to brush through, using it vertically at the corners for precision.
How much product is in the tube?
0.34 fluid ounces, per the listing.
This review is based on the manufacturer's stated formula ingredients, wear claims and application design as listed. It is editorial analysis of the specifications and features as described, not independent wear testing of this specific mascara.