Home & Kitchen Best Cookie Cutters for Delightful Celebration Bakes
P
By the Pickpedia Team
·1 picks compared
·Last verified September 2026
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Pickpedia earns from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are paid links, and we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never affects our picks or scores.
Quick answer
The Ateco 5757 nine-piece plain round set is the focused cookie-cutter pick for bakers who want graduated circles for cookies, biscuits, pastry and sugar paste. The cutters range from 0.9 to 4.1 inches and share a 1.4-inch height. Choose shaped or fluted cutters when a decorative outline matters more than size progression.
Why you can trust this guide
This guide uses published manufacturer information and exact product identifiers. The recommendations describe fit for the uses discussed here. We have not performed hands-on testing or assigned performance scores.
This guide uses Ateco's exact specifications. It does not report a cutting or release test, and plastic cutters still need appropriate dough temperature and cleaning.
Our top picks
The official Ateco page identifies nine ABS cutters from 0.9 to 4.1 inches in diameter. Each is 1.4 inches high. Ateco describes the plastic as sturdy and suitable for dough and sugar paste. Choose the set when one recipe or project uses several circle sizes. It can support sandwich cookies, biscuit portions, pastry vents and fondant details without mixing unrelated sets. Skip it when the design requires stars, letters or a fluted edge. Also confirm that the largest circle fits the rolled dough and baking sheet plan.
Selected configurationAteco 5757 nine-piece plain round cutter set
Pros
- The official Ateco page identifies nine ABS cutters from 0.9 to 4.1 inches in diameter.
Cons
- Skip it when the design requires stars, letters or a fluted edge.
Who should buy it
- Choose the set when one recipe or project uses several circle sizes.
Skip it if
- Skip it when the design requires stars, letters or a fluted edge.
Check price on Amazon ›
What to look for
Compare cutter formats
Format: Graduated plain rounds; Useful for: Multiple cookie sizes, biscuits and layered designs; Main limitation: Produces circles only. Format: Novelty shapes; Useful for: Themed celebration cookies; Main limitation: Narrow details can trap dough. Format: Fluted rounds; Useful for: Decorative pastry edges; Main limitation: Not a plain outline. Format: Metal rings; Useful for: Firm thin edge and molding; Main limitation: Material needs different care.
Prepare dough for a clean cut
Roll the dough to the recipe's target thickness on a stable surface. Chill sticky dough when directed. Press the cutter straight down, then lift without twisting unless the recipe calls for a different technique. Place cuts close enough to reduce rerolling while leaving room to lift each piece. Repeatedly worked dough can change texture, so plan the layout before starting. Wash and dry the cutters according to Ateco's instructions. Nest them only when dry, and avoid storing heavy tools where they can deform the rims.
Frequently asked questions
What sizes are included?
Ateco states that the nine cutters range from 0.9 to 4.1 inches.
Are the edges fluted?
No. Model 5757 is a plain round set.
Can they cut sugar paste?
Ateco lists dough and sugar paste as intended materials.
Do round cutters guarantee equal cookie weight?
No. Dough thickness and density also control portion weight.
The verdict
Ateco 5757 nine-piece plain round cutter s...
Choose Ateco 5757 when graduated plain circles support your baking and decorating plans. Select another edge or shape when the outline itself is the main design feature.
Check price on Amazon ›
Our top pick, secure checkout via Amazon
Note: Availability and specifications change often. Always confirm the current details on Amazon before buying.
